News

Why can’t Parliament fix its own home? A conversation with Jesse Norman MP - Parliament Matters podcast, Episode 165

20 Nov 2026
Image © House of Commons
Image © House of Commons

Who’s in charge of fixing the Palace of Westminster? Conservative Shadow Commons Leader Jesse Norman MP tells us why he blames successive failures of political leadership for the mounting cost of Restoration and Renewal, and what a three-month review could achieve. Would another rethink help Parliament get on with the repairs? Plus, Norman argues that speeches made for social media are weakening Commons debate and sets out how MPs could improve it. Listen and subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · Acast · YouTube · Other apps · RSS

Who’s in charge of fixing the Palace of Westminster? With projected costs potentially running into tens of billions of pounds and a parliamentary decision still awaited, Conservative Shadow Leader of the House of Commons Jesse Norman MP tells us why he thinks the Restoration and Renewal project needs an urgent rethink.

He blames successive failures of political leadership for allowing the scope and costs to grow. He calls for a three-month review to pin down what work is essential, what it should cost, and who should be accountable for delivering it. Ruth and Mark press him on what another review would achieve, the Conservatives’ share of responsibility for past delays, and whether a project that could span several parliaments needs a government minister to drive it forward. They also discuss why comparisons with the renovation of the Cathedral of Notre Dame and Buckingham Palace only go so far.

The conversation also turns to what happens inside the Commons chamber. Norman argues that speeches designed to yield a 30-second social media clip make it harder for MPs to build on each other’s arguments. Could shorter questions and a firmer steer from the Speaker help? He makes the case for more time to examine legislation on the floor of the House, and for select committees to use their influence more assertively.

Finally, Norman reflects on what writing about Edmund Burke and adapting his political novel The Winding Stair for the stage bring to his work as an MP.

00:00 Introduction 02:00 Jesse Norman on becoming Shadow Commons Leader 03:00 What happened to the art of Commons debate? 05:00 Shorter questions and a firmer steer from the Speaker 08:00 What the Commons loses when experienced MPs leave 14:00 How well does Parliament examine legislation? 15:00 Treaty scrutiny and Parliament’s role in military decisions 18:00 Should select committees throw their weight around? 19:00 Why has the cost of restoring Westminster risen? 22:00 What would a three-month review achieve? 24:00 Who should lead the project? Lessons from London 2012 28:00 Which repairs are essential? 30:00 Does Westminster need a minister in charge? 33:00 A possible vote and the question of party whipping 35:00 Who bears responsibility for the delays? 39:00 From Edmund Burke to The Winding Stair 42:00 Ruth and Mark on whether another review would help 45:00 What can Westminster learn from Notre Dame and Buckingham Palace?

Jesse Norman MP. © House of Commons

The Rt Hon Jesse Norman MP

Jesse Norman MP

Jesse Norman is the Shadow Leader of the House of Commons. He has been the Conservative MP for Hereford and South Herefordshire since 2010. He was in Government as a junior minister at various times between 2016 and 2023. He chaired the Culture Media and Sport Select Committee from 2015 to 2016. Before entering politics he was a Director at Barclays and researched and taught philosophy at University College London, where he obtained a PhD. He is the author of many books, including a 2014 biography of Edmund Burke and a 2018 account of the life and ideas of Adam Smith. His first novel, The Winding Stair, about the rivalry between Francis Bacon and Edward Coke, was published in 2023.

Please note, this transcript is automatically generated. There may consequently be minor errors and the text is not formatted according to our style guide. If you wish to reference or cite the transcript copy below, please first check against the audio version above.

Intro: [00:00:00] You are listening to Parliament Matters, a Hansard Society production, supported by the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust. Learn more at hansardsociety.org.uk/pm.

Ruth Fox: Welcome to Parliament Matters, the podcast about the institution at the heart of our democracy, Parliament itself. I'm Ruth Fox.

Mark D'Arcy: And I'm Mark D'Arcy. Coming up in this week's pod ...

Ruth Fox: The Conservative Shadow Leader of the House of Commons tells us why an urgent rethink is needed on the mega project to renovate the Palace of Westminster, the home of Parliament.

Mark D'Arcy: Jesse Norman blames a decades-long failure of leadership for the huge escalation in costs now facing the restoration and renewal project.

Ruth Fox: And he also laments the dying art of parliamentary debate.

Mark D'Arcy: So listeners, in this special episode, we journey to Portcullis House, which as you'll hear, [00:01:00] is within earshot of Big Ben, and we talk to Jesse Norman, and there was plenty to discuss, not least, the long delayed restoration and renewal project, which is mired in controversy as the projected costs escalate to tens of billions of pounds.

Some in Parliament have taken to referring to it not as R&R, but as D&D, dither and delay.

Ruth Fox: Successive governments have balked at committing the money, but it's rumored that the long-anticipated decision about the next steps may be put before MPs and peers before Christmas. This week, Jesse Norman wrote about his concerns in the Financial Times, and the Lord Speaker, Lord Forsyth, has expressed his worries in a four-page letter to peers.

Mark D'Arcy: Now, in a 16-year parliamentary career, Jesse Norman served in any number of ministerial jobs, chaired a select committee, and led a parliamentary rebellion over Lords reform, and now he's one of Parliament's usual channels, one of the business managers who thrash out how the work of the Commons will be conducted.

Ruth Fox: So we began our conversation by asking him if there had been any big [00:02:00] surprises now he's privy to the innermost workings of the House.

Jesse Norman MP: I think I had a pretty good understanding of how things worked. As you say, I'd been a, not just a minister on the other side, but also a select committee chair. I'd been on the Treasury Committee for five years.

I'd been on the Defence Committee for, I don't know, three or four years now. So I had a pretty good sense of it. But also, of course, if you're always interested as I am in the British constitution, you have a, a feeling for how these matters develop, and you also have a perspective from which to come to reviews to where they're not going as they should do.

Mark D'Arcy: And are they?

Jesse Norman MP: Broadly, I think the constitution is intact, and my rather controversial position might be that it demonstrated its flexibility and capability in the face of the Brexit votes. We didn't have a revolution in politics, anything like the one they've had in America with the change in the nature of the executive under Trump.

But I do think that there are things that could be done much better. One we may [00:03:00] come on to, which is the way in which they think about infrastructure, procurement, project management, which I think is at the moment pretty hopeless and dysfunctional. And another one inside the chamber is basically a, a view that over the last few years there's been so much disruption that a lot of the governing logic of the way the chamber works has become forgotten by the successive generations of MPs in 2019 and then in 2024.

So a little example of that would be that it's now absolutely standard for members of Parliament to get up and ask a question or make a speech entirely based on their read of a particular topic in relation to their own constituency And that is something that, of course, has always been part of the representative function of members of Parliament.

But the idea that really what you're driving towards is a 30-second soundbite that you can repeat on Twitter or Instagram or others is deeply corrupting to what would [00:04:00] previously been considered the orderly process of debates. Debates in Parliament used to be regarded as compendiums of wisdom, and the reason for that was because there was a rule that you could never repeat a point that had been made in the debate.

And because of that, the debate had to have the character of an accumulating body of shared experience. Therefore, it had to have a direction and a flow, and it flowed from that logic that you couldn't make a responsible contribution. You would be shouted down by your colleagues on all sides of the house if you hadn't attended, not just in person, but mentally from the beginning of the debate, followed it, followed the track of the argument, and stood ready to contribute to it.

Now, at the moment, we have these atomized debates where no one is interested in the flow of the debate. There isn't a flow particularly. It never escalates in any intelligible way. You simply get point-scoring, shouting, and referrals to one's own personal media channel, and that's deeply corrupting to the natural wisdom that's built [00:05:00] into our evolved system of parliamentary democracy.

And I'd love to see that returned to, and I think measures that we could take through the Modernisation Committee or directly from the chair would be very helpful to making that happen.

Ruth Fox: And what kind of measures would they be then from the committee and, and particularly from the chair?

Jesse Norman MP: Well, the Modernisation Committee could say that it thinks that in general, members of Parliament should not, after a certain period of time getting to know the ropes, read questions or read their speeches, and they should not repeat points that have already been made in debate.

This could be reinforced by the Speaker. Now, doing it three years into a parliament is, I think, something that might make it hard to do. But you could certainly do it at the outset of a new parliament. Say, "Look, these are the rules." And by the way, the chair could be pretty punitive on questions that go on too long.

I mean, the clerks had to circulate a note recently to colleagues across the house to say questions should be kept short in the cause of the orderly flow of debate. And they [00:06:00] could have gone further and said, "We would expect a question to take no more than 25 seconds. It might have three sentences. Here is the context, here is the issue I want to raise specifically, and here's the request to the minister."

And anything more than that just gets closed down.

Mark D'Arcy: As you say, it might be rather hard to impose that halfway through a parliament. Do you think that the house authorities are convincible that that's the way to go, or do you think that alternatively, there may not be much enthusiasm for trying to change the way it goes because its focus is a sharper light on what a government's doing?

Jesse Norman MP: Well, I don't think the House authorities should take a position on what the government is doing, but I think they should take a position on effective scrutiny of whatever government there may be. And this would permit more questions, it would permit more intelligent debate, it would permit the greater accumulation of wisdom by members of Parliament, and a more orderly process of discussion in, in the chamber and in Parliament generally.

And that's nothing but good in my view

Ruth Fox: This is a problem [00:07:00] on all sides of the House. All the parties have, have obviously had cons-considerable amount of churn, new members coming in since twenty ten really. Have you, as Shadow Leader in the Conservative Party, tried to sort of drill that into colleagues on your benches?

Jesse Norman MP: I think all parties are guilty in some respects of this. Obviously, the Conservative Party is a much smaller group than it was, you know, even three years ago. And so there is a, an ability to behave in a more coordinated and mutually respectful way, and, uh, you can see that across pol-politics. It's pretty obvious that the Conservative Party is a very united body in Parliament at the moment.

There's no leaking from the Shadow Cabinet, uh, et cetera, in a way that there might have been in almost any previous Shadow Cabinet across any previous, uh, Parliament. So that I think is obvious. Now, what is made particular precious is that in some of the smaller parties, the lack of parliamentary presence in their judgment needs to be offset by a greater social media presence.

And so you'll get this habit, and it's, I [00:08:00] won't mention any particular MPs, of well-known high profile figures dropping in, you know, asking a question and then leaving, as though what they really cared about was their media presence on radio or TV or online. And that again, is disrespectful for Parliament and I think very damaging to the flow of debate and discussion.

Mark D'Arcy: Now, you're a, a sixteen-year veteran. You came in in twenty ten at the start of the David Cameron era, so that makes you one of the longest serving MPs in the House. Now, the, the massive churn and turnover over successive elections, twenty fifteen, twenty seventeen, twenty twenty-four, means that there's a lot less collective experience out there now than there used to be.

How else does that manifest itself in the Commons?

Jesse Norman MP: Well, it's kind of you to say that. I actually feel as fresh and excited and energized as I was on my first day lit-literally in Parliament. I mean, I'm hopeful to be readopted soon, and I said to my constituency association I'm as excited about being a member of Parliament now as I [00:09:00] was as a candidate in two thousand six.

And also, not just that, but that I feel that what you can add with increased experience and knowledge of the place obviously goes up over time and your ability to act as a representative is enhanced as a result. The difficulty isn't, if I may say so, just the loss of collective knowledge, which has been significant with the changeover and increased volatility in the nature of Parliament and the shorter terms on average that MPs have had.

It's also a creeping idea that actually it doesn't really matter So you find a lot of members of Parliament who will say, particularly of a more radical disposition, who say, "Look, why do I care about this fuddy-duddy institution that takes place in a very old building and according to these rules that I don't understand?

What really matters is what I think is right at the particular moment." And you get a kind of rhetoric of individual conscience coming out in individual knowledge. This is a mad form of rationalism and egoism and arrogance, which frankly is only cured by [00:10:00] repeated knowledge of the chamber, because what that does is to breed not just respect for colleagues, but respect for Parliament and also respect for its procedures.

And time and again, it turns out that an MP who comes in saying, "Well, this is all completely mad, I've got a much better idea," quickly has to acknowledge that actually there's an internal logic which they didn't understand when they come in, and which has a life and energy of its own. And it's standing, as someone who's written a lot about history and philosophy, it's a standingly strange fact to me that people can be so respectful of evolution in the sciences and in biology, and not respectful of evolution in our social institutions and in our political institutions.

But of course, every time we make a mistake, a serious mistake, Parliament tends to change to try to accommodate that or to address it. And it may change wisely or not wisely, but on the whole, it tends to change in a way that reflects collective wisdom. In that sense, it encodes an enormous amount of collective wisdom of successive generations of parliamentarians over five, six, seven hundred years.

We should be respectful of that, and we should understand that we aren't the people who [00:11:00] invented the problem for the first time, and therefore the desire to renew the world and start everything all over again is actually not just misguided, but actively dangerous and damaging.

Ruth Fox: When you were appointed as shadow leader by your party's leader, by Kemi Badenoch, did she sit there and say, "Jesse, you know, this is what I want you to do with the role," or set you any particular tasks or say, "Go away and do some blue skies thinking about how the, the Commons and the chamber works about this institution"?

Jesse Norman MP: Uh, I- I'm not gonna discuss private conversations between me and the leader. Nice try, Ruth, if I may say so. But no, I think, I'd like to think the reason I was appointed was because Kemi thought I was the best person for the job, and also could bring a perspective to it that did combine some of these different angles and some of these different experiences, not just as a parliamentarian, but also obviously as someone who'd thought a lot about the Constitution and, and written about political philosophy and written about, you know, the lives and the histories of some of our greatest thinkers.

And all that stuff is very useful. I mean, the thing [00:12:00] so odd about Parliament is we venerate, again, this culture of youth and, and I don't disrespect that at all for one second, but it does mean that w- the normal logic of parliamentarians, which is that you would come to Parliament as a second job, having had a lot of previous experience, and you would do that in order to put that experience at the benefit of public service, has been slightly lost.

And so people come in thinking they can all be the next Churchill, you know, um, a bit of time in the army, a bit of time as a journalist, by the way, without anything like the compendium of knowledge that he built up in a very short period of time. And soon you come in in your 20s, and you'll be in the Cabinet by your late 20s, and, um, that's a terrible, terrible weakness.

It's an insane form of arrogance, and I have to say, as a good Burking conservative, I believe that reform and attention to the detail of our constitutional arrangements always works out better in the longer run.

Mark D'Arcy: Do you have in mind, and did perhaps Kemi Badenoch when she was appointing you, have in mind that idea that this was who you are, this was the view you [00:13:00] took?

And does that lead to ideas about changing the architecture of Parliament in any way, changing the system of committees, or changing the way that the House works?

Jesse Norman MP: Well, in due course, if we have any views on that matter, all will be revealed. I mean, Kemi is a very smart human being, and she's also unusual as a leader because she's very team-oriented, very long-term, and very systematically minded as an engineer.

So she's not thinking about a narrow political advantage, although, of course, you know, there's a normal argy-bargy of party politics continues. She's thinking about how you actually change the country and how you prepare now to change the country. And that, in a funny way, it commands respect. And yeah, the Conservatives had their heads kicked in in the twenty twenty-four election.

But actually, I think people in this country recognise quality when they see it, and they'll see that when they look at the plans that we're making. And not just that, the personality, the character, the thinking that's gone in behind that.

Ruth Fox: So in terms of your evolving [00:14:00] thinking about how the place works, what's your views in terms of, you know, if we're to have a more effective parliament, the strengths and weaknesses, for example, of the legislative process?

Jesse Norman MP: It's such a huge topic, Ruth, that I should be asking you that question rather than me. Uh, I do think that the legislative process is being obviously tested at the moment in ways that it hasn't been before. So we were talking earlier about the failures of debate in the House of Commons. We've had a very large number of general debates when what we actually would be much better served with having is debates of the committee of the whole House on legislation and getting back to the scrutiny function of our chamber.

That's almost been entirely lost. That is a s-standing embarrassment to successive governments and successive parliaments that they have not exercised that scrutiny function. It's also an insult to the representative function and therefore to the people of this country who elect MPs to exercise scrutiny.

And of course, when you combine that lack of scrutiny of secondary legislation in the [00:15:00] Commons with the lack of scrutiny of statutory instruments and secondary legislation Which I'm, I've no doubt is a, a regularly recurrent theme in the Hansard Society reflections. Yeah,

Mark D'Arcy: yeah, not kidding. That is Ruth's favorite subject-

as she always tells us.

Jesse Norman MP: Well, well, well, some sixth sense, uh, suggested to me that might be the case. Uh, uh, th- then both primary and secondary legislation processes need to be revisited and rethought.

Mark D'Arcy: Also, I suppose another category that fits that argument is, uh, international treaties. Andy Burnham may come back from his European summit with a treaty, and treaty scrutiny in the House of Commons is famously perfunctory.

Jesse Norman MP: Yes, I feel slightly differently about that, and that's because a, as a good constitutionalist, I recognize the importance of prerogative powers of the Prime Minister in foreign affairs and in Defence and security matters. So I tend to think that we could strengthen the interrogation after the event of those treaties, but I would, as with, for example, the decision to go to war, which I think has been catastrophically mishandled [00:16:00] by successive governments, notably Blair in relation to the Iraq war, but also the Cameron decision to put the decision to bomb Syria in front of the House.

Those are just terrible, terrible mistakes. The House cannot substitute its judgment for the judgment of the trained people it has in the field on these matters, and when it does do that, it dips its hand in the blood, and it makes it impossible for there to be scrutiny. That's why we had to have three successive independent inquiries into the Iraq war to get to the bottom of some of the disasters that occurred.

If they'd, if they'd just gone ahead with it, then Parliament could have exercised its function and held them to account in the proper way. So again, the less you know about the Constitution, the more you end up replicating its failures. That isn't to say we couldn't improve the scrutiny ex post of treaties, and I'm sure we should.

Ruth Fox: Do you think there's a, a concern, though, that compared to 100 years ago when the Ponsonby Rule, which governs these things, came in, this idea of laying a treaty for 21 sitting days before the House to decide, you know, whether the House will consent for it to be ratified or say to the government, "No, go away and think [00:17:00] again."

Do you think there's a, an argument that the way in which treaties have developed and their sort of reach into domestic policy, economic policy, s- things like data, human rights, environmental matters, labor rights, and so on, that that strains, uh, the scope, if you like, of the prerogative as it was originally intended, and actually th- therefore Parliament needs also something a little bit further upstream in terms of the mandate?

Jesse Norman MP: You are trying to lure me into deep waters there, Ruth. I'm failing, clearly. And, um, I'm, I'm, I'm... No, I'm, I'm not gonna comment on matters that fall into my colleagues in the Shadow Cabinet's remits. But- I think it's a very well-known fact, and the report by David Wilson confirms it, that there is a concern that in the area of human rights, for example, there has, in particular since 2010, been a huge expansion that was unexpected because of the, of the emerging doctrine of the convention as a living instrument, and this has catastrophic effects.

All these, um, you know, Article 2-type prosecution attempts to renew the prosecution of people who fought in [00:18:00] Northern Ireland would be an example of that. So we mustn't be naive about the domestic effects of international treaties, but I think that's, um, a slightly different matter. What could happen, of course, and what doesn't happen at the moment, is that the committees could take more interest in these matters, and the committees, I'm afraid, are not really quite exercising their function.

When I was on the Treasury Committee, Andrew Tyrie and I and colleagues thought very hard about holding specific inquiry and hearings on the, um, Financial Services Bill and one of the, uh, financial regulation bills, and we were able to threaten that if changes weren't made to the way in which the court operated in the Bank of England by legislation, we would, as a committee, vote against it at, um, the committee, uh, stage of the process in the House.

That was a sufficiently powerful threat. That's... And committees ought to be doing that. They ought to be throwing their weight around. Unfortunately, we have at the moment where because of the size of the imbalance in the political parties, the Wright Committee's view, which was [00:19:00] that chairs should be elected across the House, doesn't really apply.

I mean, the Labour Party can tacitly whip the chairs of its own parties, and they will be elected no matter what the House thinks, and that, I'm afraid, rather undermines the independence of the committee chairs, and it means they're not quite as punchy in those cases as they should be in holding treaties, legislation, ministers to account, and that's a slightly unexpected weakness in the post-2010 system.

Mark D'Arcy: We turn to an issue that's very much in the purview of the Leader of the House and the Shadow Leader of the House, which is the restoration and renewal of the old Victorian Palace of Westminster before it burns down, falls down, floods with sewage or whatever disaster might befall it. You've written extensively in the Financial Times this week about the bloated cost, as you describe it, of the proposals so far, the multi-billion pound bill for this proposed renovation.

Why do you think this project has become so expensive?

Jesse Norman MP: Well, my [00:20:00] Financial Times article was just the latest of a whole series of things that I've written privately and publicly, and that includes a letter that I wrote to the client board on R&R in December of last year saying that these decisions were hopelessly poorly meditated and I thought potentially disastrous.

So I suppose you have two or three questions. One is, what is the nature of the proposals and why should they be opposed? And then the second is, how have we got to this point? Now you've asked the question, how have we got to this point? There's a very simple reason for that, which is lack of political leadership What should have happened, in my judgment, is that the parties should have been convened early on to set the broad outline, to be briefed and informed about the situation, and then to set the broad outlines of a budget and a scope and a timing of works.

And then a board should have been put in place that just reflected that consensus and that party [00:21:00] input. And that should have been a very small enterprise and very closely joined up with the speakers of both houses, and so that you were able to get a cross-party, cross-house decision emerging by which the parliament could be guided.

What's actually happened has been colossal successive failures of political leadership. And of course, the clerks, um, whether from reasons of high-minded or low-minded reasons and others, have expanded under enormous bureaucratic and lobbying pressure the brief so that we now have a situation when it was put in the online, uh, a couple of days ago that you could build a Notre Dame every week between now and a year's time and have enough money left over for a nuclear-powered aircraft carrier with the sums at the upper range of what's being proposed.

Now, that's completely insane. It's a new HS2. No thoughtful person should be anywhere near that. So I've suggested that we do need to have a completely different approach. We should not be prolonging [00:22:00] the discussion unnecessarily. The government may argue that actually any further discussion would be prolonging it.

That's a very weak argument. The government could have brought a motion on this matter in January or February of this year and failed to do. We're running ten months late already. And what I suggested is we need a three-month period with a kind of red team of the kind I've described that just nails it down.

We can't not have a budget. We can't not focus on the stuff that actually needs to be done. We don't need airport lounge type arrangements in the House of Commons. We need the problem that we have to be fixed and the building to be restored. That's the focus. And if we do that and we're sensible at how we manage it across parties and across houses, I think we can get somewhere sane.

But we can't do it with the current proposals as they're contemplated.

Ruth Fox: You've got to go back 12 years for this, where we got the first options review 2014. And then the thinking at the time when the Conservatives were in office, and there was a joint committee of both houses to look at this and to look at the governance arrangements, their conclusion was, I think very much influenced by the [00:23:00] Olympic experience, was that you needed to take the politics out of it and have this independent body that would, would manage the process and keep the, the politics out.

There was then a change of view that no, that the politics needed to be put back into the system, and it's, it's now this, this governance model, the politicians more involved. But going back to what we were talking about earlier on political churn, there's no consistency at political level because of the turnover of, of members of the House of Commons Commission, for example.

And what is going to be different about this that is going to ensure delivery in three, five, 10 years' time, and particularly the vexed question of decant. Whatever the study has been in the last 12 years, it's found that decant, b- one or both houses leaving for a period of time, is cheaper than staying in.

So if that is still the case under your model, would you support a, a decant of one or both houses for a [00:24:00] period?

Jesse Norman MP: Uh, if I may say so, I think your analysis is quite wrong, and it rests on an ambiguity in the word political No one is suggesting this should be party political. This is a matter of House business, and the political parties may differ on generally on matters of whether or not you should throw enormous amounts of public money at a proposal.

I'd be slightly surprised if the government believes you should do this, if it, if you're asking it in its private heart, because what that means is £20 to £40 billion worth of investment in London by a government that's promised to make investments in infrastructure outside London and to decentralise power away from the metropolis.

So I'd be slightly surprised if that was actually their position. But the need for political leadership is the need for leadership within the House at a political level across the parties in relation to the bureaucracy and in relation to the clerks and the other officials who are being asked to carry this stuff out and all of the other bodies.

And if the description you gave was accurate, then entirely the wrong lesson has been learned because, of course, the way the Olympics worked, first of all, if [00:25:00] you recall, the budget was enormously expanded late on in the Olympics when they realised that they'd got it completely wrong, and the only reason we feel well about it is because it was such a triumph, and we're apt to ignore the fact that actually the process until the final few years was pretty disastrous.

But also it had a qualitatively different client function. It was vastly better. The client was sensible because you had Tessa Jowell running it from within the government. It was a government matter. You knew where it was coming from. There was a department in charge. You had a great minister in charge, and she was really driving it forward.

Then you had a client entity to whom she had reposed power that included people like Paul Dighton and Sebastian Coe, who absolutely know their business. We don't have anything of that kind at the moment. We've got a delivery body headed up by a, a very good team who've been essentially put on standby for 10 months while the government decides not to do anything with the motion, spinning their wheels, desperate to get on with it, I have no doubt, and we don't have any kind of client function.

If you have spent any time looking at infrastructure projects, and I have run the infrastructure projects while I've been the minister responsible for the Infrastructure Projects Authority a- and for the National [00:26:00] Infrastructure Commission and, you know, a whole bunch of other stuff, and I ran the campaign against PFI, and I many years ago worked on Wall Street and then in City of London.

I've got some experience in this area, and it's ... failure of infrastructure projects is like 80 or 90% the failure of client. If the client's not doing their job, you do not get the careful scrutiny of the process required to achieve the right outcome. Classic example, you're rebuilding your house, okay? The builders come in.

Do you say, "Fantastic news, I'll see you in 12 months," or are you there every morning to say, "What about this? What about this? What about this? What about this?" That's the client function. That's what's been egregiously missing at this point. We need to restore that, and the only way you do that is by getting political leadership of that small P political kind that I've described.

Mark D'Arcy: Very difficult though to get that kind of leadership through a diffuse web of different committees. You've got the view of the House of Lords, the view of the House of Commons expressed through the Lords Commission, the House of Commons Commission, and together divide by two. It's like being trapped in a badly staged production of Waiting for Godot.

Jesse Norman MP: Yeah, I mean, I think that's a clever line, but I don't think [00:27:00] it's particularly accurate. The commission at the moment in the Lords is quite competent. The commission in the Commons is competent. There's no reason at all why delegated members of those commissions oughtn't to be put on a board that actually gets on with it under leadership.

Because we, we just need to form it. And, and of course, it means that some people who would like to have chip shots aren't going to get their views respected. The way you handle that is by early politics to talk to those people and understand the nature of the thing. You slim down the client function, and then you have a delivery body that responds to it.

That's all doable

Mark D'Arcy: And at the same time, is the underlying problem here is simply everybody in politics is running scared of what the Daily Mail will say when there is a clear, definite plan to spend X billion revamping Parliament.

Jesse Norman MP: Well, I'm suggesting to them that if they're worried about what the Daily Mail will say when they are planning to spend twenty to forty billion pounds, just imagine how much better they'll feel when the number's, uh, some tiny fraction of that, which is what I think it could be done for, and what I think the evidence is from the various delivery bodies that it could be done for, if you just focused on the bits that need to be doing.

Safety, of the utmost importance. Building [00:28:00] structure and the stonework, yes. The concern about fire hazards, yes. Of course, that stuff is essential. But after that, you start to get into areas where I'm not sure we do need that. But you're not going to know that until you have a proper client actually drilling down.

Ruth Fox: So, so what are those areas where you think we should slim down and not do them? I mean, asbestos wasn't on your list, so I assume that we, there's an acceptance that asbestos should be dealt with.

Jesse Norman MP: Asbestos is a classic example. The rule on asbestos, I am not an expert in this, but the people who know what they're talking about tell me, is that asbestos is okay if you leave it in situ.

What you cannot do is disturb it, and if you disturb it, you have to take it out, and that's a very expensive and difficult system. So if we have some asbestos, as thousands of buildings do around the country, we need to make a decision about whether it is encapsulated and left where it is or whether it's moved.

I'm not sure there's been any ... These, these air tests detect the whole time. I'm not sure there's been any serious worry about asbestos in the air supply around Commons recently, but then there may have been, and we should look out for it and make sure it isn't an issue. But what we shouldn't do is be running after some perfection.

Let me give you another little example. [00:29:00] The arrangements have been made on the expectation that it would be wrong for the House of Commons and House of Lords not to play their part in moving towards net zero. Completely agree with that. But the government's moving away from its concerns about net zero.

There's a lot of public concern about that. It's enormously expensive. Maybe it would be sensible to look at alternatives that are much cheaper, that involve other fuel sources. Those are the kinds of things that aren't even being questioned at the moment because of a certain kind of reigning dogma, and they're very, very expensive.

And by the way, let's not think of it in some abstract number. This is your taxes and your taxes, Mark, and these are people's money which otherwise would go on things that they want, like effective roads and good public services and all the other things that make our lives actually work.

Ruth Fox: I think the thing that's difficult for people outside, including ourselves, to understand is why isn't this already happening?

I mean, what is going to be different between the, the model now, where you've got the political leadership on a cross-party basis, and what you want to move towards? [00:30:00] Because you talked earlier about, well, you know, the commission, the, the client, you know, they're competent, l- let them sort of get on with it, lead and provide the focus of what the work should, should be.

But why can't that happen now?

Jesse Norman MP: I mean, the client board has probably got 40 members on it at the moment. There's a programme board which probably has another 20 to 30 members, I mean, including all of the adjunct quasi-members who attend all these meetings. The infinite wisdom of the team that's running this has been to create a third board which would sit somewhere in between the two for purposes of delivery.

I mean, it's completely mad. It's like a kind of Ptolemaic expansion of the epicycles of, uh, you know, models of the universe. It just-- We need a Copernican revolution to cut through all that and just give us a, a client and a delivery body and let them get on with it.

Ruth Fox: Do you think that one of the problems with the governance model is that actually there isn't enough ministerial direction?

It cuts across the grain constitutionally that this is a, a project [00:31:00] for Parliament, but ultimately the government has to make the decisions about the funding and the allocation. And does it need that kind of Tessa Jowell figure somewhere in the process to help provide that focus and drive across parliaments, across both houses?

Jesse Norman MP: I think it's very, it's a very difficult problem to solve because the whole issue here is the lack of leadership that reflects the dispersion of political authority, and it is very notable. And I say this as someone who's, was a minister for six or seven years and was obviously on various committees, as you know, and I'm pretty brutal in holding ministers to account.

And when I was in, for example, in the Treasury, and indeed in any ministerial job, my rule was that if I ever had a civil servant with me, which I tended to not want, that they shouldn't speak for the first hour of the discussion. And there's a very simple reason for that, which is I think political accountability confers authority.

So I want the [00:32:00] minister to be on toast and cross-examined, and as a minister, I want to be cross-examined because it creates my, increases my authority, my ability to speak to an issue. In this case, we don't have any of that accountability. No human being-- If you ask the question, who's in charge of R&R? No one is in charge of R&R.

If you ask the question, has there been any scrutiny of budgets that remotely approximates to the kind of work that would take place inside the Treasury or by Treasury ministers or by the Treasury Committee of Public Expenditure? Absolutely not at all. Has any human being been grilled publicly? No.

We've had no debate on this issue in Parliament for, uh, many months and no debate in particular since these cost year proposals were produced in the beginning of February, and that's just simply not acceptable. And so the suggestion that we're going to approve these things in some motion to come in the next few weeks, and then it will go back to the Treasury and Treasury must write a check for £3 billion, I personally find insulting as a taxpayer.

So you have got an issue here. We need to find, to be clever and [00:33:00] find some mechanism by which Parliament can endow a person, ideally, or if necessary, a body, with the degree of authority required to get the job done.

Mark D'Arcy: My ears pricked up there at the, the mention of a motion in a few weeks' time. As a, as a usual channel, do you now have a, a sense of that this is coming down the track in the nearer future b-before Christmas perhaps?

Jesse Norman MP: I, I don't know, but I think it's widely believed across Parliament that we'll get a motion at some point soon. They were delaying till after the budget because they didn't want to have a motion mentioning £20 to £40 billion immediately after a budget whose principal political theme had been we're surrounded by very serious national security, financial, and other problems, and we're going to do nothing about them.

Ruth Fox: You've indicated, I think, or 'cause Kemi Badenoch has, that you intend to whip on that vote, which would be unusual in the sense it's been historically regarded as House business. And going to your earlier point about we need political consensus across the parties, I take your point. This is not a party political matter and shouldn't be one.

But doesn't that raise the bar a bit in [00:34:00] terms of the party political edge to this? And i-if, if you're right in terms of the governance and in terms of the finances, you know, many of your colleagues would undoubtedly have serious concerns about the kinds of money we're talking about, so why do you need to whip it?

Jesse Norman MP: I don't think any, uh, statement has been made about whether or not the Conservative Party's whipped on the matter. But if I may say so again, I think you're making a mistake. The fact that something is House business, in my view, does not automatically, as people might think, rule out a whipped vote or something approximate to it.

Don't forget, there are degrees of whipping. I mean, I'll give you an example. So, as I think I've indicated, the Labour Party seems to me to be tacitly whipping on select committee chairs. They won't outright say anything, but that's what it's doing. In the case of the Conservative Party, I think a lot of my colleagues, pr-probably almost without exception, are just deeply concerned about the lack of visibility and transparency, the immensely elongated and expanded cost, the lack of clarity on scope, and the lack of, uh, uh, quality of, [00:35:00] of leadership.

And so they'll just, just vote on those issues. But there's a further problem which I think puts more pressure on your position, if I may say so, Ruth, which is the government's bringing a motion at some point It's been going to bring a motion since December of last year when the client board met to approve the costed proposals, which were then put into this report at the beginning of February.

How is the taxpayer to exercise any accountability on a motion or to a government to bring forward a motion if it's not by some mechanism of small P political action? You cannot have this stasis. You cannot have the hypocrisy of saying, "We can't have any further delay" while we delay 10 or 11 months.

You have to have some sense of consistency of purpose and of accountability and transparency, and that's, I think, where the, the rubber is going to meet the road on this topic.

Ruth Fox: Do you accept, though, that there's some responsibility on your party for this as well, though? Because prior to 2024, so that 10-year period, your party was in government, your predecessors as leader of, of the House.

You know, we had all this, [00:36:00] these governance changes. We had delays. We had, you know, this let's, let's look at the option of going to York for the House of Lords. Let's tear up the governance model and come up with a, a different approach. Let's look at the option of staying in the building for the entire duration of the works.

That's contributed to considerable delays. I mean, like, if you go back to the original report, I mean, by now, much of the work would've been done at far, far less cost. In a sense, it's on all the parties. It's on all the members of, of the House.

Jesse Norman MP: I absolutely do not exculpate the, uh, Conservative Party or the coalition government of 2014-15 or the Liberal Democrats or indeed the Labour Party from this problem.

And if you notice, my criticism has been over the last 10 months because that's when the proposal was put in front of us. We could have had a vote- Mm ... in February on those proposals, and we haven't. That's been a government decision not to do that. And the reason I mention it is because it disables the argument that we shouldn't spend three months actually getting our act together now if this vote, if there is a [00:37:00] vote and a motion at some point, fails.

And I don't see how it can possibly succeed because if it's obvious whether whipped or not that one or more than one political party is thoroughly opposed to something, and one house has deep concerns, and you'll note that the Lord Speaker of the House of Lords has just sent a letter today expressing severe concern about this.

So that consensus which a, an effective and competent administration, both the previous ones and this one, would've been building for political-led change doesn't exist either between the parties or between the houses. And of course, that's before you get to all the other distractions that have existed since 2016 and the run-up to 2016, and I don't think anyone should make excuses for that.

But obviously, the House was convulsed with a whole bunch of other issues that it was concerned with, and that's been part of the failure of political leadership more widely that no one really was able to pull the House together to make this political judgment.

Ruth Fox: So is one of the possible changes that needs to be made to the governance to [00:38:00] enable the client function to operate in the House to give the commission or whatever body it, it is that you adopt for the client function to lead it forward in a more focused way, smaller body, more focused, is for it to be able to table motions in the House rather than it all having to hang on waiting for the government to do it?

Jesse Norman MP: Uh, that's an interesting idea. I haven't thought about that. Or you could just have a convention that if such a body were created or such an entity were created, which it could be, of course, Parliament could do anything, therefore it can do that. But it could be a matter of agreed convention that when that body wishes to lay a motion in front of the House in the name of all the political parties that are composing that consensus, if you like, even if n-not all of them are represented, then, and in the name of both Houses, probably on consultation with the Lords, then the government would lay it without delay.

That's the kind of innovative thinking you would need to get this thing actually moving properly.

Mark D'Arcy: Changing the subject radically here, you're a published author, a biographer of Edmund Burke. You've written a [00:39:00] novel, The Winding Stair, about politics at the turn of the 16th, 17th centuries. Um, there's now a play based around that novel in performance in London at the moment.

Do you anymore have time for that sort of thing, or is political activity, Shadow Cabinet activity now crowding out your, your previous cultural activities?

Jesse Norman MP: Do you mean time for writing? Well, I, I wrote the stage adaptation of The Winding Stair over about two and a half years, and it's not a particularly long script, so I don't think that's a, a huge problem.

No, but there's a general issue here, which is I personally think that one thing you should-- you haven't mentioned, which I think in, you know, one should mention, is that I'm also chairing a new university in my constituency, which is trying to revolutionize higher education by making it much more, no less academically rigorous, but, but much more vocational in the way that things are taught, and that opens it up to kids of much more diverse, less well-off backgrounds.

And I think it's the solution to how you solve some of these serious embedded skills problems in the UK, and we're doing that in [00:40:00] Herefordshire and, and I'm looking to do, uh, many elsewhere. But on this, I personally don't think there's any ambiguity or conflict here. I mean, Burke says that politicians should be a philosopher in practice.

And so that means not just being a doer of deeds, but a speaker of words. And you, you can't actually be a doer of deeds because action is not action in its full sense without getting too philosophical, if it hasn't got a governing intention behind it. So you have to reflect on the principles of your politics, the principles of your action, in order for your action to have any meaning or indeed to be intelligible to other people.

So I think writing about Burke and Smith and Edward Cooke and, uh, Francis Bacon, as I have done, is a way of making politics and indeed the way in which our modern society has developed economically, politically, and legally, and scientifically intelligible to a wider audience. That's all in a part of, uh, the desire to create a better understanding within which effective public action can succeed.

That's something I spent twenty years trying to do.

Mark D'Arcy: It's just that so many [00:41:00] people in Parliament find politics so all-consuming that there seems to be very little time left for anything else. You're, you're actively fighting against that.

Jesse Norman MP: No, I wouldn't say that at all. I, I'm just... People have different priorities, and they have different things they w- they want to care about, and I try to avoid making as few compromises as possible.

And I'm very lucky because in Hereford, I have a team of three who work for me, combined age a hundred and ninety. They've worked for me for forty-seven years overall, and they s- have stopped me from making so many mistakes over the years that it's not even funny. And, and it's very interesting because whatever my view might be, and it might o- might be on a very rarefied constitutional, philosophical, political topic, you know, I will run it past them, and they will tell me stuff that I didn't know and hadn't thought of, and it's unbelievably helpful.

So I think that's part of the-- certainly part of my solution has always been to be incredibly lucky and surrounded by the people you have around you.

Mark D'Arcy: Jesse Norman, thanks very much indeed for joining Ruth and me on the pod today.

Jesse Norman MP: My pleasure. It's been a very interesting conversation. Thank you

Ruth Fox: Well, Mark, what did you make of that?

I mean, you know, [00:42:00] restoration and renewal, as listeners know, it's been a long-standing, uh, topic of discussion on this podcast. We may perhaps be getting to, uh, the next steps in the, in the coming weeks, but Jesse Norman clearly got big concerns and not minded to vote for it without a review.

Mark D'Arcy: Yeah, the trouble with that, I think, and, you know, there are plenty of reasons why you should have a review.

The costs just look enormous and very difficult, I suspect, for governments to justify in an era of austerity when billions are being sliced off public services all over the place and billions more are needed for Defence and all sorts of other purposes as well. So looking at that, you can understand why the costs are such a painful issue.

I can't help thinking, though, surely sharpening what restoration and renewal was supposed to do and bringing it closer to what MPs wanted it to do was surely the, the point of the last attempt to revamp the structures to deliver it. Yeah. And here we are again with another proposal for another revamp of the structures before we get round to actually putting one brick on top of another, practically.

So I'm really not sure whether another [00:43:00] revamp will do anything just because I'm a gnarled, old cynic and remember all the promises that were made at the last revamp.

Ruth Fox: Yeah. I mean, this is the problem, isn't it? You talk about a client. The client is Parliament, but as our conversation made clear, you know, there's diffuse centers of power and leadership and responsibility.

In Parliament there are many

Mark D'Arcy: mansions,

Ruth Fox: yeah. Yeah. And, and just think about what's happened since that first report was published in twenty fourteen. The political churn is part of the problem. The fact that one Parliament, in effect, can't bind another. So we've had four general elections since that first options report was published.

We've had two House of Commons Speakers. We're on our fourth Lord Speaker. We're on our tenth Leader of the House of Commons. We're on our eighth Shadow Leader of the House of Commons. And they've all had different views about how it would be done, how it would be fixed, different governance models. So yeah, I struggle to see what an additional review is going to fix unless you sort out who is in charge, who's the [00:44:00] client, who's the point of responsibility, who's the point of accountability.

And I regret to say, because it goes against all the sort of the constitutional grain in terms of this should be a parliamentary project, not a government project, but ultimately I just cannot see at the moment how it happens unless the government gets a grip and a government minister is appointed as the R&R minister to lead on it.

Mark D'Arcy: And indeed, if the Treasury is going to be prepared to sign the check. Yeah. Because that's absolutely the key point here, has always been the cost. Now, if, as Jesse Norman hopes, a further revamp of the governance structures leads to a set of proposals that look an awful lot more affordable, so much the better.

The trouble with the way these things have happened up to now is everybody's had a pet project. I mean, the pod last week, I think I was talking about mine, so I'm just as much to blame as everybody else is. Everybody wants to add their additional bells and whistles to it. And remember, you've talked about what's happened so far.

Imagine what might happen when the project's actually underway. It may well be Go across three different parliaments, any number of [00:45:00] speakers, governments of several different colors. And so- And that- Things could get pretty chaotic in the future, couldn't it?

Ruth Fox: Yeah, and that, that's why a minister may also not fix it, 'cause you'll have political churn with a, with a minister, which will be problematic.

But at least it would be within some kind of sort of ongoing structure, and you could have some accountability structure. But I'm struggling to see at the moment how a revamped version or a slimmed down version of the House of Commons and House of Lords Commission at the moment is gonna fix this.

Mark D'Arcy: Yeah, indeed.

Um- It's a bit of a multi-headed monster, the governance of Parliament. It's never worked especially well. It's certainly never been particularly transparent, and that's because there are so many players within it.

Ruth Fox: Yeah.

Mark D'Arcy: And that always makes everything very difficult. Uh, someone once defined a committee as an animal with more than six legs and no brain.

And, uh, well beyond that threshold- Yeah ... for the governance of the Houses of Parliament, I'm afraid.

Ruth Fox: And that's, that's why I find some of the comparisons to Buckingham Palace and Notre Dame- Mm ... and the restoration of those buildings a bit frustrating.

Mark D'Arcy: Well, with Buck House, there was certainly very little doubt about who was in [00:46:00] charge there.

The

Ruth Fox: client. No, it's very clear.

Mark D'Arcy: The king. They wore a crown, you know. And,

Ruth Fox: and frankly in, in Notre Dame's case as well, it was also clear. The president of France made very clear what he expected and what he wanted. Those projects show the importance of the kinds of things that Jesse Norman was talking about, the governance model, the client clarity about what they want, what things should be done in what order, and, and the budget, and the timescales about the governance arrangements.

Mm. But they are of a different scale and scope and complexity to Westminster. And-

Mark D'Arcy: I mean, people have talked about Notre Dame and the site of an iconic national monument going up in flames obviously galvanized France. And were, heaven forbid, a fire to consume the Palace of Westminster, I imagine there would be an awful lot of soul-searching in this country.

But you can get Notre Dame several times into the Palace of Westminster. It's a vast site. People don't necessarily appreciate that just from the sort of- Yeah ... pictures of red buses driving past. It's huge. Yeah. Much bigger.

Ruth Fox: You know, I'm a football fan, so to use a [00:47:00] football analogy, Notre Dame is about the size of one big football pitch, one standard sized football pitch.

Westminster, you're talking 16. Mm. Notre Dame also had been emptied out because it was being ... You know, the fire happened when the renovation was taking place, so it had already been emptied out. They'd already sort of worked out those plans. But in essence, it's a single large space with a basement underneath.

The, not just the footprint, but, you know, the complexity of, of the work. I mean, the number of windows, for example, in Notre Dame, I think there's 113 compared to 3,700 at Westminster. Similarly with, with Buckingham Palace, the size and the scale and the complexity- And in those buildings, I mean, Buckingham Palace, yes, they had to think about, well, what do we do with things like state visits?

Well, funnily enough, the King has other palaces and other castles, and they moved it- Other palaces

Mark D'Arcy: are available.

Ruth Fox: Yeah, they moved it to Windsor Castle, so they could accommodate that and m- and make provision for it. But comparatively, the staff numbers in [00:48:00] Buckingham Palace are significantly smaller than the number of people that, that, the footfall in Westminster.

You're talking about decanting two houses of Parliament, the members, which themselves, depending upon how many, you know, members of the House of Lords turn up on any one day, but y- y-

Mark D'Arcy: Getting on for 1,000 right there.

Ruth Fox: Yeah, a- absolutely. And then you've got all the s- the, the staff of the, the House of Commons members, then you've got some peers have got staff, but then you've got all the staff of, of, you know, the committees, and the chamber, and the audiovisual teams, and Hansard.

You've got all the, the library staff, you know-

Mark D'Arcy: Don't forget the journalists.

Ruth Fox: The jour- the journalists, yeah. Uh, so it's a whole level of different operation and scale. So whilst I think there's of course lessons to be learned from Notre Dame and Buckingham Palace, and we should try and learn them, sometimes people are pitching those cases in quite simplistic terms.

Mark D'Arcy: Well, maybe, Ruth, when we get to the point where we know that a decision is due to be debated in the Commons and indeed the Lords, we should do a bit of a [00:49:00] deep dive into some of these issues, have a much closer look at these huge costings- Yeah ... these vast figures that are bandied about, and explore the whole thing.

I think it might be helpful to our listeners, and it might even be helpful to, uh, the parliamentarians as well.

Ruth Fox: It might. Well, we should do that, Mark, yes, so let's wait and see when the debate's taking place. But suggestions are it'll be before Christmas, so we may not have long to wait.

Mark D'Arcy: My fingers are crossed.

Ruth Fox: See you next week.

Mark D'Arcy: Bye-bye.

Outro: Parliament Matters is produced by the Hansard Society and supported by the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust. For more information, visit hansardsociety.org.uk/pm, or find us on social media @HansardSociety.

Subscribe to Parliament Matters

Use the links below to subscribe to the Hansard Society's Parliament Matters podcast on your preferred app, or search for 'Parliament Matters' on whichever podcasting service you use. If you are unable to find our podcast, please email us here.